Marwane El Kharbili

Showing posts with label PhD. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PhD. Show all posts

Jan 11, 2009

Thoughts about systematic literature reviews

Some time ago, I had posted a two-piece item about systematic literature reviews.
Then came the following comment by sebastian:
... I think you are discussing here planning vs. intuition. Your way of approaching the literature review is intuition. Kai is planning. Personally, I think both ways will lead to success as long as you have some checks to make sure you are on the right way.
Yeah, I will have to agree on this one, since I have been doing literatire reviews for 18 months now. The only problem is that I still think that at least one single strong systematic literature review, which is carefully planned (i.e. choices of selected literature can be justified by more than intuition, relationship to other works, relevance for the tackled topic, celebrity of the working group, recency, impact factor, kind of publication, signification of results, et...) is necessary, at one stage or the other in a PhD. The reason for this is simple, it is easier from the researcher's perspective to make a clear map of the literature when usiny a systematic approach, the complexity can then be gradually increased. It can also help spare some analysis time, since comparison dimensions are known and well-understood. The intuition-based version, requires the ability of dealing with a huge amount of information, and still keeping a clear view on the massed of information, without loosing track of the real aim of the literature review. It is the hardest variant and I would say the most dangerous. In short, intuition is extremely important in research, and most often works best, every researcher will tell you this. Systematic literature review is a top down approach where the "publication population" for a certain topic is analyzed before publications are selected, and the more intuition based one is rather bottom-up, since the classification and analysis of the literature is done based on the already selected literature. The question is whether these two approaches always bring the same results? No way to tell this for sure. But we shouldn't forget that the real goal is to make good research, to reach new goals, not to make a perfectly written literature review.

Marwane El Kharbili

Dec 22, 2008

Having a PhD Strategy (Part Two)

This is the second part of my reaction to this post by Kai, a fellow PhD Student at Blekinge TH and Ericsson AB. I had already introduced his blog and you can find the previous part in the previous post on this blog. In this post he reports among others about two other courses he has to take besides from software productivity. I will try to shortly analyze what he wrote about scientific publications and statistical methods.

About scientific publications, what interested me is that they get to study scientometrics. Scientometrics, according to Kai, are the methods used to assess the relevance and importance of journals and scientific conferences. If you have worked as a researcher you must know that not all scientific conferences, workshops, symposia, journals and all sorts of scholarly transactions are equal. They surpass each other in terms of popularity, reach, perceived quality and influence on the scientific community. Using Scientometrics, the impact factors of journals are established, which helps the researcher to select where he wants his papers to be published. as Kai simply expresses it: if you get a paper accepted on one of the journals with the highest impact factors for your community and area of research, then " this increases your reputation as a scientist in the area". But logically, the difficulty to get a paper accepted at one of these conferences grows with their impact factor.

What they learn in this course is to asses the impact factors of target journals and conferences, the major scientists (what my supervisor calls immediate research community), to come up with a strategy of publication and to make a review of papers. I guess the latter concerns papers that have been accepted at famous scholarly transactions or that have been written by members of the major scientists in the community.

Knowing the major scientists in the community is very important. First of all you get to know the most important directions of research, and you get to know the most important results already achieved. So you get a lot quicker to know the state of the art of the area you are working on. Also studying the references used by these scientists can help you know the foundations of your research area that you may want to read for a solid and fundamental understanding of current state of the art results. these scientists are the ones that publish the most articles and the ones at the most important transactions. These scientists normally also show you at which journals and conferences papers tackling related topics can be published and which ones are the most relevant.

The second course are statistical methods. Now, like every computer scientist I have had my share of statistical mathematics. Actually more, due to the emphasis put onto mathematics and the additional statistics options I took at my engineering school, the ENSIMAG, Grenoble. But this is not what Kai is talking about. He specifically says that they take a course dedicated to learn how to use statistics to evaluate and analyze data gathered during research (especially in software engineering, the use of case studies as qualitative analysis tools is widely done, as I can see it from the work of Sebastian). Such use cases and the accompanying statistical analysis can be of great use when tackling one of the last steps of a PhD, which is evaluating your results. The course is based on concrete problems, in 5 seminars.

The goal of these two posts was to give an idea about how a structured PhD at a university (at least partly) takes on the harsh project of a dissertation, and the tools PhD students get to learn and to use. In a totally industrial PhD, you have to try to go as structured as possible with the tools that you have. That means you shouldn't expect to have time, resources to learn or mentors who will teach you how to optimally get on with your PhD. You are in quite some extent an auto-didact, a multi-disciplinary researcher and necessarily one with extended curiosity. The desire to work in a highly structured way and the ability to combine several sources of information, from areas that do not necessarily have much to do with your direct area of research, is a must. being open to learn from the techniques of others and to get the best out of all who you meet or you read about can only make your PhD better.

I hope that my two small analyses have helped better explain what an industrial PhD is about. I will write some other posts about this, since I have quite some opinions to share concerning the topic.

Marwane El Kharbili

Dec 1, 2008

Having a PhD Strategy (Part One)

This is my reaction to this post by Kai, a fellow PhD Student at Blekinge TH and Ericsson AB. I had already introduced his blog.
In this post he reports about his (at the time he wrote the post) next steps for the PhD, He lists three courses he has to take at the university and explains ho he wants to approach the PhD Thesis.

Kai explains that he is going to do what is called a "Systematic Literature Review" (SLR. A systematic literature review is different from a normal Literature Review (LR) in the following points:
  1. Allows to analyze the current state of knowledge about a whole scientific Area, such as Software productivity (Kai's example) or Compliance Management (my example).
  2. It is easier to see what has been done in an area and what hasn't been done yet.
  3. It is easier to argue why a PhD Student took a certain direction, and why this direction of research will bring outcomes which are useful to the scientific community.
  4. It also easier to motivate the use of certain methods, tools or approaches.
  5. it typically covers a way wider scientific scope than a normal SOTA (State Of The Art) review since it doesn't seek to focus on a certain problematic as an efficiency criteria.
But the main difference resides in the following quote from Kai's blog:
  • "Systematic means that one has to document search strategy (keywords, search strings, scientific databases), paper selection criteria, paper evaluation criteria, how to synthesize the findings of the identified studies and so forth."
So the main and real difference to a normal SOTA is the strategy. Strategy in the sense that you'll have to select what you are looking for, in terms of setting keywords and search strings, and where to look for references. Moreover, the selection of papers returned has also got to be documented in the strategy. the final part of the strategy being the specification of the LR's results analysis and synthesis. I imagine the last point means that you would have to define a set of dimensions/axes on which you would want to project the results of your research, in order to get what is relevant for you from the LR. One of the main deliverables after this Systematic LR is a taxonomy of the domain of research and solid material for one (or maybe even) several papers. These papers are an important way of synthesizing results of an SLR because they are a way of consolidating the SLR results along one or several axes of research and because they are of high utility to other researchers. Thus, quality SLR papers have their place in highly regarded research Journals. They are also an archived and extensible knowledge basis of the domain. An SLR also makes it easier for the PhD student to later write related sections in research papers, so the big overhead of conducting an SLR can become a good investment.

I was surprised. I had never heard of the clear specification of a Literature Review (LR) strategy. of course you have always your own strategy when conducting one, but it is only "in your head" and your are the only one who knows what you are really looking for. In addition, no one would bother to describe an LR´s strategy because it would not be of a direct use for the expected outcome of the LR. So I was very intrigued. I think that in the scope of a PhD Thesis, dressing strong, clear and most importantly far-reaching fundamentals for the dissertation is a requirement for the thesis. That's why I am really convinced of the utility of a Systematic Literature review (SLR).

The most interesting in this is that I have noticed my non-intended attempt at the beginning of my PhD to do the same for my Thesis. For example, my attempts to have a taxonomy of the domain were in the form of complex mind-maps. Unfortunately , Minds Maps do not scale wekll with complex research domains, you will need a structured approach using several mind maps on several layers of the same domain and use hyperlinks between the mind maps. But I thought (mostly due to comments from colleagues and my entourage) that I shouldn't go for it because it is just a waste of time and that I should focus a lot more on certain topics. Knowing my tendency to tackle a lot wider range of reources to solve one problem (which I call the Sponge Effect (SE) which I will come to later in this Blog), in an attempt to let no information escape my research I thought I had to stop it. But this is not the main reason.

The real reason is that doing a PhD in 3 years necessitates extremely focused work on getting results for a well defined problem. The main fear of a PhD student is not to be able to fully understand the problems he has to deal with and to need a lot more years to conduct his research than intended. This is the real reason why my working method has been to cluster the domain I am working on in sub-domains, and studying one of these sub-domains fully in order to achieve some results for this sub-domain. My strategy is to examine the results I get from my research on this first target sub-domain in comparison to the other sub-domains afterwards. And thus to be able to get a more global overview on my first intended target PhD Domain by criticizing, completing, correcting and extending initial results. Whether 3 years are enough for this, I really doubt. But hope keeps alive :D

Marwane El Kharbili

May 15, 2008

Securiy Requirements Engineering PhD & PostDoc

I wanted to make some advertisement for a double vacancy at the department of computer and information science at the NTNU (Trondheim, Norway). One position is a PhD position and the second one is a Post-Doc position. Both positions are ensured for 3 years (August 2008 - July 2011) and comprehend work on a new project, the ReqSec project. The projects seeks to come up with a methodology and tools for security requirements engineering.

The topic of security engineering is ons that I am interested a lot into, and I believe that we are are far behind on security issues from a software engineering point of view. One of my probable future directions of research (which I had talked about with my professor even before starting my PhD) is security modeling for business process management. the motivation: Security requirements do not solely appear on the lowest layers of software development, many types of security concerns get their requirements and partial specifications from the business and strategic layers of an enterprise model.

The ITMEE faculty of the Trondheim university is a leading university in computer science of which I know from personal experience. Some of my classmates at the ENSIMAG in Grenoble, went to the university of Trondheim in the same year I went from Grenoble to Karlsruhe. Several research institutes in applied mathematics and computer science also exist in Trondheim, some of them private. I don't know much about Norway or Trondheim itself but I guess if you're into nordic charm and love mountains, forests, Fjords and the see you should be happy there. Like Morocco, Norway is a kingdom too.

N.B.: [IT @ NTNU] Faculty of Information Technology, Mathematics and Electrical Engineering at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU) in Trondheim, Norway.

Marwane El Kharbili.

May 5, 2008

Kai's PhD Blog from Sweden

Another link to a PhD blog here, after the one about Sebastian's. This one is by Kai, a friend of Sebastian. I don't know him personnally, but I have found his blog interesting. He does hos promotion at both the Blekinge Institute of Technology and Ericsson AB, so he's in an industrial PhD program too. He tackles questions of software engineering. so drop by and leave a nice comment :D

Marwane El Kharbili.

May 2, 2008

Have you got a PhD Blog too?

I had previously registered my blog on PhDWeblogs.net. The idea behind this is to make the blog accessible to people also doing a PhD or just simply having interest in research, who do not necessarily share the same interests I have in computer science and economics. Last week I stumbled upon this other website, which looks like way more accessible and better done: http://www.wissenschafts-cafe.net/. Apart from having an very appealing name, the site covers several disciplines and offers a number of services to bloggers. You can enter a description and a link to your blog, and make it accessible from the website to other people interested in what you are doing. I even got the hard bloggin' scientist sticker of the website's creator on my blog.

Have fun!

Marwane El Kharbili.

Apr 20, 2008

PhD Thesis

I am an international cotutelle PhD student enrolled at both the University of Luxemburg and the University of Osnabrück (Germany), as part of a collaboration program between both universities. My area of research is software engineering and I am particularly interested in developing a method and language for regulatory compliance modeling and verification. For more details about my research interests and contributions have a look at my research page.

I am writing my thesis under the supervision of:
Previously to this, I was working for the IDS Scheer AG in the ARIS Research department. I was involved in international research projects on semantic BPM also tackling compliance management issues. During this period I authored and co-authored several scientific publications (see my publications page). I was also involved in the design of the business rule management solution of the ARIS platform for business process management.

I submitted my research proposal to Professors Pierre Kelsen and Elke Pulvermüller on October 2008. The proposal got accepted during the year 2009 and I officially started working on my thesis on August 2009. My research on compliance in business process management had already begun druing my duty at the ARIS Research in June 2007.

Mar 2, 2008

Get your PhD Blog on the web!

I have just registered for an account on PhDWeblogs.net. As the name says it, this website acts as a registry of all PhD blogs there is on the web, at least those that registered. You can scroll blogs by topic. Currently there are 500 of them. I will report on it if I get to get any special advantages from being on the site. For the moment the only things I learned is that Marlene Charlotte Larsen from Aalborg University in Denmark found out that 31% of all danish internet users between the age of 12 and 18 spend 2 hours or more per day on the internet... :D

Marwane El Kharbili

Feb 13, 2008

PhD position at ARIS Research Open now!

At ARIS Research in Saarbrücken, we have currently an open position for a software engineer with the possibility of a PhD. The position is meant for 3 years. Supervision shall be made by the Wirtschaftsinformatik Institut at the Universität des Saarlandes in Saarbrücken.

The position comprehends work on exploring the uses of web 2.0 technologies in conceiving context dependant and business process supporting telecommunication services.

PhDing in an industrial environment brings many advantages. Apart from working at the world leader in Business Process Modelling and Analysis, the position would allow you to build your career path in the industry, profit from the experience of people in various domains, work in a young anf highly motivating environment at ARIS research while conducting research on very challenging and demanding domains.

If you're interested, then have a look here at the position description, or send an email to jobs AT ids-scheer DOT de. I have to add that german language skills are required for the position since it os the spoken communication language here at the IDS. Some detailed information about the expected tasks, what the IDS has to offer to accompany a postgraduate work and how a PhD at the is organized is to be found on the blog of my colleague at ARIS Research: http://sebstein.hpfsc.de/2008/01/24/web-20-und-bpm-promotion/.

In case of any questions you may contact me at: Marwane DOT Elkharbili AT ids-scheer DOT com.

Marwane El Kharbili.

Feb 12, 2008

Fulltime POSTDOC in Semantic Technologies, STI International, Vienna

I have to make a quickie here. It is a bout a Postdoc position available at the STI2 International in Vienna, Austria. STI2 is a world leading institution in semantic technology Research (which is obvious if one knows that STI stands for Semantic Technologies Institute). STI2 is a regroupment of stakeholders in semantic technolgies from the academic, industrial and governmental communities.

The Postdoc position will require a person with an excellent PhD degree and some experience in semantic technologies. The exact description of the position is to be found here.

Marwane El Kharbili

Jan 31, 2008

How I came to the IDS

How did I came to doing a PhD? And why at the IDS? And why BRMS? This is the topic of this post. So I will tell the whole story now, for you hords of curious fans :D

I worked at SAP headquarters in Rot-Malsch (just a train station before Walldorf, 40 minutes in train from Karlsruhe) as a student in the Business Process Modelling team for almost a year. As part of my tasks I had to model and develop using the ARIS Framework from the IDS Scheer. I came into contact with consultants from the IDS.

At the same time I was working on my master Thesis at the FZI at the university of karlsruhe, where I was doing my double degree in computer science (with the ENSIMAG-INPG in Grenoble, France). My master thesis topic was about policy-based collaboration in semanic business process management. I had already decided some time before that I definitely wanted to work in reasearch and do a PhD. As I am of a very communicative nature, I had told almost everybody in the company (and that makes a lot of people :-)) about what I was doing and that I was looking for a PhD position to continue working around semantic BPM.

Through one of the consultants who was in contact with an IDS engineer who already was doing his PhD at the IDS, I doscovered that the IDS also had a research division and even a PhD program. Since the IDS offered what I needed for my PhD Project, I decided to jump on the opportunity and sent my application through my contact. I was contacted by email and after some phone interviews (which I was used to since I have had numerous professional experiences previously, I also had many interviews with french companies, at a time where I thought I would go back to work in France...) and a few other interviews at the IDS headquarters (also with my current supervising professor), I received a contract proposal in Karlsruhe in february. I signed immediately and sent it by post the following day.

I still had to finish my master thesis, to get my marks from my french engineering school validated and converted at the faculty of computer science (which took some time...). After all administrative difficulties at the university were overcome, I had to apply for a work permit in Karlsrueh and wait. Thanks to my IDS superior's insistance , the procedure was highly accelerated and I got my work permit at the beginning of june. I started immediately. I had already moved to saarbrücken in May.

I said goodbye to Karlsruhe and closed one chapter more of my dislocations in European countries and a prolongation of my stay in Germany of at least 3 years :D

We'll see how it goes here, and if I get along well with the city and life here in saarbrücken. Hope for the best.

Marwane El Kharbili

Nov 8, 2007

About this blog

My name is Marwane El Kharbili and this is my PhD blog. I am currently doing my PhD at the IDS Scheer AG (ARIS Research) in Saarbrücken, germany and at the University of Osnabrück.

On this page I will try to document the progress of my PhD. I would also like to use this blog as a collaboration platform and alternative publication channel for the many ideas that one has to deal with and encounters while meeting so many people working on so many different topics. Discussion and collaboration are noticeable imperatives of any work, but it certainly doesn't get more critical as in scientific work.

My Topics of interest are of course Business Process Management (BPM), Business Rule Management Systems (BRMS), Governance, Risk and Compliance Management and Semantic technologies. SOA related aspects, Process Modelling, Analysis and verification as well as Requirements Engineering might well get on board, since there are no clear boundaries between all these disciplines and as an IDS researcher, one comes inevitably to deal with these.

I hope this will provide some of you with interesting information and bring up some interesting discussions. Wish me good luck and don't hesitate to mail me in cas esome of my writings catch your curiosity!

Marwane

About this Blog...Again

I started this a little bit late, since I am at the IDS since already 5 Months. But as I am convinced of the interest of managing such a blog, I will maintain this blog throughout my PhD. The documentation and communication potential of keeping such a virtual notebook are immense and wasn't it the high amount of tasks and challenges one has to face when starting his professional career, I'd have been doing this since a long time ago (I already hear the Blog-wolves laughing and thinking "Well, you'll have even less time when you get olderbuddy" :D).

One of the things that always kept me reminded that I'd eventually have to start my own PhD blog, is that it seems that today, everybody has his own PhD blog, starting with Sebastian, my colleague here at IDS and fellow PhD student. If you look at how often people in the IT branch have blogs, and the quality of content some of them produce on these blogs, one is astonished. It is certainly a high cost to produce such quality, and PhD students are not well placed in terms of time availability :D

I am one of those guys who somehow alwayws have 1000 projects and find it very hard to bring each one them to the end...well almost ;-) So I thought this should not also happen with my PhD Blog project and decided to get started just today. But I have learned through years to optimize my energy...I still need to work on my prioritization of tasks, which sometimes gives the impression that I am not well organized, but when people have a look at the amount of things I have to deal with in my mind, they understand that one sometimes has organization problems. As far as the PhD is concerned, Organization of time, of tasks and an intelligent prioritization are an absolute necessity. And on the contrary to what many people think, there are lots of software tools which can really help, if one knows which ones to use and how to use them. I will often deal with organization and work methods here in this blog, since this I have always been trying to optimize.

So, this blog is not a premature infant, it is destined to deal with business and scientific topics, most of them research related. But I will also try to present what a postgraduate dissertation in an industrial context really looks like, and why one should or should not opt for it. Organization and work methods are also a great topic of interest to me, so don't hesitate to let me know if you have interesting things to tell about it. For now, the slot I reserved for writing this post is over, I'll get on with the next task for today :D

Marwane